Land

Oversupply or Overreaction? DFW Market Needs To Hit Reset

Scott Finfer breaks down the DFW-area oversupply crisis: post-pandemic assumptions, slower job growth, and mispriced inventory. Across the U.S., high-volume markets face similar risks. Finfer outlines five strategic moves to cut through the noise — and seize ground as bigger players pull back.

Land

Oversupply or Overreaction? DFW Market Needs To Hit Reset

Scott Finfer breaks down the DFW-area oversupply crisis: post-pandemic assumptions, slower job growth, and mispriced inventory. Across the U.S., high-volume markets face similar risks. Finfer outlines five strategic moves to cut through the noise — and seize ground as bigger players pull back.

June 30th, 2025
Oversupply or Overreaction? DFW Market Needs To Hit Reset
SHARE:
SHARE:

There is a short-term inventory oversupply in the Dallas-Fort Worth area.  

And if you ask around, including the best-of-class operators, things are tense right now. Those are facts.

It’s a knife fight. Some will lose fingers trying to outrun carrying costs rather than resetting expectations.

What is not clear is:

  • How did we get here?
  • Will equilibrium be reached by burning off the inventory?
  • Is there still demand?

How did we get here?

DFW has been one of the hottest housing markets in the country over the last decade, driven by explosive population and job growth. Builders raced to meet demand, fueled by cheap capital, institutional appetite, and record-low vacancy rates. But the Fed’s rapid rate hikes and stretched affordability created a mismatch: homes were delivered into a market that had suddenly cooled. Many developers didn’t hit the brakes fast enough.

Now the hangover is here.

Will equilibrium be reached by burning off the inventory?

That depends on how disciplined the market becomes. The current oversupply, especially in entry-level and suburban product, could be absorbed if builders pull back starts, price appropriately, and let time work. However, if landowners and capital stacks continue to press for velocity, the burn-off will be slower, and the pain will be shared.

Is there still demand?

Yes, structurally. North Texas remains a magnet for jobs and migration. However, demand today is more discerning, rate-sensitive, and cost-conscious. It’s not that people don’t want homes, it’s that they can’t or won’t buy at 2022 prices with 2025 rates. The question isn't whether demand exists, but whether it can be unlocked at the right price point, with the right product, in the right location. Those who understand that nuance will emerge stronger.

The Real Challenge: Oversupply? Or Overreaction?

While there’s no better source of intel than the operators on the ground in DFW, it’s also true that when the world feels like it’s on fire, you can’t see the forest for the trees. The urgency of day-to-day pricing decisions, margin pressures, and inventory clearance can obscure the bigger picture.

That’s the disconnect right now: the macro signals point to a fundamentally strong, profitable market, but the micro-level decisions, often made out of fear or necessity, are distorting the near-term view.

So, where’s the opportunity?

1. Distress without distress pricing.

There are motivated sellers of land and finished lots, but they’re not yet waving the white flag. That’s a window. If you have patient capital and a long-term view, now is the time to invest in growth corridors that are temporarily underserved.

2. Build-for-rent (BFR) pivot points.

With homeownership affordability still out of reach for many, communities designed for renting households (not just homes for rent) continue to draw capital and renters. Smart builders are shifting inventory and product to this channel, where absorption remains strong.

3. Capital as a wedge.

Lenders are cautious, but equity is still seeking yield. If you can bridge the gap — either as a capital partner or by recapitalizing stuck projects — you can get favorable terms and step into deals that would’ve been unthinkable 18 months ago.

4. Entitlements and shovel-ready land.

While builders fight to move homes today, few are lining up new starts for 2026. That opens the door to entitle and position well-located tracts now for resale or vertical integration later — when the fog lifts and visibility returns.

Bottom line: Uncertainty breeds inaction. But those who can separate signal from noise, macro strength from micro chaos, can buy smart, reposition assets, and come out of this cycle with leverage.

Why the Opportunity is Big Now

1. Public Builders Are in Retreat Mode

  • They're focused on maintaining volume, not expanding.
  • Many have paused lot takedowns, renegotiated land deals, or walked away from future phases.
  • They’re scrutinizing every start, which slows velocity and weakens competition.

2. Entitled & Developed Land Is Stranded

  • Developers are sitting on ready lots with fewer takers.
  • Absorption uncertainty creates price softness great for land buyers who can move quickly.
  • You can pick up finished lots or nearly-ready land at a discount, often with soft terms.

3. Subcontractor Availability Improves

  • Labor capacity opens up when publics pause starts, creating better pricing and scheduling.
  • Private builders with local relationships can leverage this to move faster and build cheaper.

4. Market Demand Isn’t Dead, It’s Just Confused

  • Interest rate shocks slowed sales, but demographic drivers haven’t changed.
  • Migration, household formation, and DFW’s jobs engine are still strong.
  • Buyers are waiting for signals, and there’s upside as soon as confidence returns.

5. Less Competition, More Share

  • Fewer builders actively delivering product means private builders can gain market share.
  • Spec opportunities exist in underserved price points.

How to Capture It

  • Be Nimble: Move into submarkets where publics have paused but long-term demand is solid.
  • Buy Distress Quietly: Finished lots, broken option contracts, or mothballed phases can be acquired off-market.
  • Control the Vertical: Even if you don’t want to build, control the land and sell pads to smaller builders.
  • Build to Yield: BTR, model leasebacks, or holding rentals short-term can bridge absorption gaps.
  • Know the Local Story: Use hyperlocal knowledge (schools, retail openings, job corridors) to bet on areas the nationals can’t justify.

The Contrarian Advantage

When everyone is scared, it’s time to buy.”

Buffett's logic applies here. The big guys are optimizing for Wall Street optics. Private builders can focus on long-term value and neighborhood relevance.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Scott Finfer

Scott Finfer

Principle, Republic Standard Land Fund

With over 25 years of experience in the real estate industry, Scott has acquired and developed over 12,000 single family residential lots across various markets and regions.

MORE IN Land

Land, Capital, And Control — A New Playbook In Homebuilding

Five Point Holdings’ acquisition of a controlling stake in Hearthstone points to the direction of homebuilding strategy: toward lighter land positions, more agile capital flows, and a far more disciplined focus on vertical construction, consumer targeting, and time-to-market velocity.


Engineering The Path To Better, Faster Growth Amid 2025's Stall

Local resistance, rising fees, and long entitlement windows are locking up growth. This analysis shows how smart financial planning unlocks new possibilities.


How Our 'Stuck' Housing Market Mutes Healthy Mobility

Our need to move socially and economically is the central theme in the recent book from Atlantic editor Yoni Appelbaum.


ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Scott Finfer

Scott Finfer

Principle, Republic Standard Land Fund

With over 25 years of experience in the real estate industry, Scott has acquired and developed over 12,000 single family residential lots across various markets and regions.

MORE IN Land

Land, Capital, And Control — A New Playbook In Homebuilding

Five Point Holdings’ acquisition of a controlling stake in Hearthstone points to the direction of homebuilding strategy: toward lighter land positions, more agile capital flows, and a far more disciplined focus on vertical construction, consumer targeting, and time-to-market velocity.


Engineering The Path To Better, Faster Growth Amid 2025's Stall

Local resistance, rising fees, and long entitlement windows are locking up growth. This analysis shows how smart financial planning unlocks new possibilities.


How Our 'Stuck' Housing Market Mutes Healthy Mobility

Our need to move socially and economically is the central theme in the recent book from Atlantic editor Yoni Appelbaum.